"All of the employees were very friendly and helpful! We drove 35 minutes to go specifically to this jeweler and they did a great job engraving a timepiece for a Christmas present. Great price, and it was done in a timely fashion. Would recommend this place if you need a custom engraving done!"

-Kevin Rice

"I needed some rings sized and some repairs made. A friend recommended Great American Jewelry. I was very happy with the work done. They are very professional and knowledgeable. I would highly recommend them to anyone looking for a jeweler."

- Mary Ann Devine

"Everyone at Great American Jewelers treats you like you’re family. They’re friendly, truthful and fair. These are the types of people I like to do business with. When you’re in need of an extravagant cocktail ring or a quaint key ring, Great American Jewelers will surely have what you’re looking for."

-Margaret Watkins

Larry is the absolute best!!! He will go above and beyond to make you happy! He works with you, explains everything clearly, which makes the process of jewelry buying a lot smoother. I 100% recommend Great American Jewelry! I could not be more pleased at how smooth and fast everything went! No such thing as a "waiting period" with Larry! He will have what you are looking for within hours if not a day or so, and I'm talking CUSTOM MADE!! Unreal!! I am beyond pleased with his level of professionalism and expertise!! The entire staff was so friendly!! Love them! Great American Jewelry will now be my lifetime jeweler!.

Laugh Through Life

Amazing experience. I was always skeptical of small jewelry shops, I always thought I was going to be over paying. Well NOT HERE!! When I came here back in June, I came in looking for an engagement ring, Marie did not disappoint me or try and up- sell me on anything, which made me so happy. She worked with my budget and actually had the same exact ring I had on my phone saved for 3 years. I will not be shopping anywhere else for my jewelry in the future. Thank you so much for making my experience the best and helping me execute my day with the perfect ring!!!

Rob Lopez

Great American has always been my go to Jewelry store. This pandemic has been a ride on tilt-a-whirl for most of us and it was my time to let go of many of things in my life including jewelry that means so much to me and others that do not. They all made this difficult process seamless and with compassion in remaking moms wedding band to creating an amazing new necklace from parts of other pieces and fixing others but with such care and sentimentality. Good honest people are hard to find and I so recommend the entire team to be there with you when it really counts. Love them thanks you all for your time and care.

xo

Kathy Frandy

It starts with beautiful jewelry. Everything in the store is beautiful to the eye, from the less expensive gifts to the more expensive pieces like engagement rings and wedding bands. While photographing a collection of rings for the owner, Larry, I watched and listened as customers came in and were greeted by name. and they were attended to by a polite and caring staff. Someone looking for a repair got the same thoughtful help as someone shopping for the perfect engagement ring and stone. If you are looking, start at Great American!

Alex Wolff

My Bad for not remembering Great American Jewelry, but that will never happen again !Of course two days before the wife’s birthday I start shopping and went to a few Jewelry places around town that didn’t really have anything I liked, and they were pushy. Luckily my son reminded me about Great American Jewelry. As soon as I walked In I was greeted by Laurie and Janet that were super friendly and helpful. Janet helped me pick out a beautiful bracelet for my with her birthstone and initials. It had room for the whole families birthstones and initials too (me and our 3 boys). The entire experience was pleasurable and I felt like I was with was dealing with family. Great selection and prices. Highly recommend them and please support our local businesses. I will certainly be back ! Thank you

Anthony Fazio

I can’t say enough positive things about Great American Jewerly. Larry, Linda and Janet were wonderful to work. I highly recommend Great American Jewerly to anyone who wants to sell diamonds.

Angela Herman

My husband and I had a wonderful experience at Great American Jewelry! Laurie and her team were super nice and very personal. They were very respectable of our budget, spent a lot of time with us and helped us in making our decision! I would recommend this store and will be back!

Mara Cebek

Amazing service. I've come to Great American Jewelry several times. Once for my fiance's engagement ring, and just recently for our wedding bands. They are so attentive, never pushy, and always make you feel at ease. Also, it's pretty telling that I'm from Port Jefferson and I come all the way to Massapequa so they are definitely worth the drive.

Gregory Parisi

Very trust worthy, knowledgeable jeweler. Beautiful quality and workmanship. Very reasonable. I would highly recommend to anyone. Would never go anywhere else!

Dan McGuirk

Professional experience with a personal touch start to finish! I had called merely to see what their hours and COVID policies were, and the owner took it a step further and engaged in my partner's interests in jewelry so she knew what to order for us to look at. Very helpful, very reasonable on price, friendly and dedicated to seeing you exactly what you want. Highly recommend Great American Jewelry!

Matthew Cooper

This jewelry store is amazing! They take the time to get to know their customers’ style and budget and each piece of jewelry that is purchased is of the finest quality and style. The ability to take old pieces that you no longer wish to wear and custom design a new breathtaking piece is incredible. Most recently I worked with Janet who took my mother-in-law’s previously loved diamonds and rubies and made two exquisite rings for my daughters. Before you purchase anywhere else you must visit Great American Jewelry. They are following all Covid protocols making the experience very safe.

Marlena Leung

Had a great experience with Janet. Spirited and enthusiastic about some new designs for old and sentimental pieces I had. The repairs I needed to make on my signature ring happened in a few days. The ring looks brand new! Anxious to work with her again and I intend to take all my business was here from now on

Marilyn Durso

I had an incredible experience with Janet as my husband and I upgraded my engagement ring/center stone and setting for our anniversary. We felt that Janet truly spent a great deal of time ensuring everything was perfect, hand-selecting the most brilliant diamonds for us to choose from, and never pushing us into a direction we weren't comfortable with. Janet was patient and never rushed us and we are OBSESSED with my new wedding set with my 2.5 ct solitaire - it is just stunning!

Maggie Meade

I dealt with Mary and Larry and had an absolutely perfect experience with picking out and putting together an engagement ring. I couldn't ask for a more personable team who really do care about your events in your life and who seem like family more than salespeople. I will definitely be back for future jewlery and hope you do too!Include some of your favorite customer quotes and feedback here as social proof, to build credibility and trust for your services and products.

Peter Masci Local Guide ・10 reviews

This is a place to go if your looking for comfort knowledge and a wonderful one On one experience there’s never any pressure and they take there time with you Iv never felt more comfortable and satisfied at an establishment in my life strongly strongly recommend this place you will not be disappointed

Chris Leo 1 review

They really did a great job in getting me the custom ring before my deadline. I actually received the ring 2 days ahead of time and it looked great. This was my first time coming to this store, so i was alittle nervous about getting the ring in time. Everyone in the store was extremely nice and made the process very smooth. Its a very comfortable environment.

David Oxford 1 review

Great American Jewelry was amazing. I brought in my engagement ring which had been over filed down by some else to get the band “shank” replaced. They did amazing work on site and let me watch. They were so kind and put me at ease. Would definitely go back

Leah W 2 reviews

Very helpful, extremely kind and honest! Would definitely recommend and go back

Danielle Gabriele 2 reviews

Went in to shop for an engagement ring for my fiancé. Was looking for loose diamonds and had a very select criteria of what I was looking for in a diamond. After sharing all this information with Janet that day she said that she would have the diamonds available for me to see in 2 days. When I came back in 2 days everything that I had ask for was what she delivered on. Her great service, listening, understanding, and kind/welcoming atmosphere from every member at Great American Jewelry made purchasing my fiancé's engagement ring such an easy process. I would recommend anyone shopping for an engagement ring to go check out Great American Jewelry. By the way, the finished product after the diamond was set came out even better than expected, it looks absolutely gorgeous and my fiancé is so happy with the ring. Thank you Janet and everyone else at Great American Jewelry for making both my fiancé and I beyond happy.Include some of your favorite customer quotes and feedback here as social proof, to build credibility and trust for your services and products.

Steven Acquavita 2 contributions

Great American Jewlers is amazing! Everyone was super friendly and inviting! Mary helped walk me though every piece of the puzzle when came to picking out an engagement ring so that I could make it truely my own. Not only was the service fantastic, but ring came out better than I could have ever expected! My now fiancè and I absolutely love it! Thank you Mary, I couldn't have done it without you!

Jesse Opitz 1 review

Super friendly and helpful. They kept me within my budget and made sure I got exactly what I was looking for.

Josh Ganshaw 2 reviews

I had a wonderful experience at Great American Jewelry. I went in looking to buy a pair of diamond stud earrings. Janet was amazing! She found a pair of diamonds that were in my price range and exceeded the quality I was looking for. The whole team was patience and helpful, and made the experience very enjoyable :) I live deep in Suffolk County and it was definitely worth the drive. I will only shop at this Jewelry store from now on......Nassau County's "hidden gem."Thank you to everyone at Great American Jewelry!

Lisa Boehler 1 review

I would not go any place else for any jewelry needs from my high price diamonds to my peridot and beautiful silver jewelry. I have had mine and my husband jewelry expertly appraised. The quality, owners and staff are worth the trip!

Christine Kadien 1 review

My fiance bought my engagement from here and he absolutely loved his experience! He worked closely with Laurie and she was so knowledgeable and helpful with the entire process. I am IN LOVE with my ring and get compliments on it all the time.We came back for our wedding rings as well and could not be more pleased with Laurie and this business. 10/10. Highly Recommend.

KAITLYN HORNE 4 reviews

Great American Jewelry is a fantastic establishment! The staff are friendly, professional, well versed in the field, and make you feel at ease!

Lauren Pingitore 2 reviews

Janet made engagement ring shopping a breeze. Everyone was super friendly, and helped me every step of the way. Great experience!

Kevin D 2 reviews

I had my finance's second engagement ring repaired there. Great American Jewelry is a great place to do business when it comes to jewelry. My fiancé and I have decided to make this our jewelry store. Mary and Larry are very polite courteous and friendly. I'm looking for earrings for my birthday in August and Great American Jewelry is the place I'll be purchasing them from! See you soon guys

Ronnie Jemison 15 reviews

I had my finance's second engagement ring repaired there. Great American Jewelry is a great place to do business when it comes to jewelry. My fiancé and I have decided to make this our jewelry store. Mary and Larry are very polite courteous and friendly. I'm looking for earrings for my birthday in August and Great American Jewelry is the place I'll be purchasing them from! See you soon guys

Ronnie Jemison 15 reviews

I had such a great experience at The American Jewelry, Larry and Laurie we’re both more than helpful and made me feel very comfortable at all times making sure I had the exact ring I had wanted special made to my liking’s. They treat you more as Family then a customer which Is what I liked the most. Highly recommend this place that’s why I wanted to take my time out to write this review. Very Thankful !

Max Colavito 1 contribution

What a wonderful experience. I have followed in my parents footsteps and chose Great American to help me design a stunning engagement ring. Yes, my fiancé absolutely loved it!Throughout the years Larry and Laurie have always treated me like family. I can’t thank them enough for making the experience so enjoyable.

Vincent Valentino

Outstanding service. Very friendly and helpful. My watch repair and polish was perfect. I can’t thank them enough. I highly recommend!

Adam E 11 reviews

Beautiful diamond. Excellent service.

Lauren Napolitano 1 review

Friendly and very attentive. A pleasant place to shop for jewelry, jewelry repairs, a gift, or in my situation selling some gold jewelry. Will highly recommend!

catherine petoske 3 reviews

I had a custom made necklace made for my wife for Valentine's day. It was exactly like the picture I had. Mary was excellent and knowledgeable. I n life you get what you pay for and quality costs. Well the quality and customer service is incomparable. My piece is worth every dime. I highly recommend Great American jewelry 👌

Anthony Robles Local Guide ・18 reviews

I recently purchased an engagement ring from Great American, and I could not be more pleased with the experience. They were very helpful throughout the entire process, and provided excellent guidance every step of the way. The ring is absolutely beautiful, it came out better than I could have ever imagined. I highly recommend their services. My fiancé and I are now customers for life (she said yes!)

Jimmy Schaefer 1 review

I purchased an engagement ring from Great American Jewelry. The team was fantastic to work with. I felt they listened to my requests and ultimately delivered on a beautiful ring. They even accepted the ring back for some minor edits and after the proposal, which was a success :). Highly recommend!

Matthew Brill 2 reviews

Great American jewelers is the place to go for custom work! I had a ring that was passed down for two generations completely reset in a new setting. Not only did they do the custom work very quickly but the price was INCREDIBLE! so honest and so fair. Will be a forever customer & recommend to everyone I know! Trustworthy and amazing work.

Elizabeth Genoa 6 reviews

Larry and Mary were an absolute pleasure to do business with. We had a family crest ring done by Great American Jewelry and the craftsmanship is beautiful. This ring will forever be in our family.

Jennifer Aguayo-Tinelli 18 contributions

Laurie and Larry really did an amazing job on helping me find the ring I was looking for. They were very professional and caring about my needs and really made it a first class experience.

Anthony Febbraro 1 review

This review is long overdue. My husband and I had the pleasure of working with Jeanine. She helped us purchase an absolutely beautiful engagement ring of our dreams! She made us feel like family through the entire process. She was patient, and answered every question we had. Above all Jeanine is extremely knowledgeable and a pleasure to work with. My husband and I would return without hesitation for any future jewelry purchases! Thank you soooo much Jeanine!

Patty Aguilella Local Guide ・11 reviews